Recap: BBQ Brawl S2E5 – “Competition ‘Cue”

Monk: In a bit of a change of pace, I’m going to try my hand at TV recapping for the second season of BBQ Brawl, which airs for *checks notes* 10 episodes *gulp* on Monday nights at 9pm ET on Food Network. 10 episodes? Well let’s see how this goes…

Well barbe-cuties, this episode kicks off the second half of the season and each team has lost at least one member with Team Eddie having lost two. Having done “hot and fast” barbecue so far this season, this week the episode jumps right in with a four meat “low and slow competition ‘cue” team challenge.

That means over the next seven hours each team am have to prepare four meats and two sides; the meats are Texas brisket, Carolina pork, Memphis ribs, and Kansas City…chicken(?). Kind of shoe-horning that KC-style with the chicken there, aren’t we? Maybe go Alabama-style even if that’s not one of the major four styles.

Right away, Christopher is visibly excited at this challenge due to his and Lu’s competition background, and his excitedness gets him into a little spat with his captain Eddie when they have a difference of opinion on the second side.

On Team Bobby, Taylor and Terry waste no time to start their bickering and Erica clutches her crucifix and says a quick prayer. Ara on Team Michael is a little concerned with just 7 hours for brisket, but thinks he can make it happen during that time.

After the longer cooks get going, we finally get to the advantage challenge which Bobby gets to pick after suffering his first defeat last week. With the contestants busy with their meats, Bobby challenges the captains to a 20 minute mac and cheese challenge. Twenty minutes isn’t the ideal time for mac and cheese, but in the end Michael’s homemade spaetzle beats out Bobby’s chorizo mac with okra crust and Eddie’s green chile mac and cheese. The advantage ends up being: the ability to use a captain from the other teams for 30 minutes which could either be used for grunt work or even used strategically to keep him from helping his team at a crucial time.

Team Bobby’s energy is visibly off, even from the judges porch, so Bobby brings the team together and helps them hash it out. Terry admits he started the trash talking, and the team elbow bumps into hopefully a better headspace. We’ll see if that can help Terry’s struggle-pork that had no rub, was cooking at a very low temp for a bit, and is getting the marinade a couple hours in. I’m not seeing how this could possibly be a winner for him.

Michael uses his advantage to get Bobby to shred some cheese and…not much else. He dismisses him early, so not much of an advantage.

Brittani’s chicken and collards are hits with three judges but Ara’s brisket is a little dry but has a good bark. David’s pork needs vinegar and his ribs are out of balance but mac and cheese ends up a winner after he smartly abandoned Michael’s waffle idea halfway through.

Terry’s open faced NC pulled pork is greasy and an affront to any NC barbecue fan. Erica’s brisket that was separated prior to cook and injected with Worcestershire sauce (“wooster) is well received, and her cuban beans are as well. Taylor’s chicken has a rubbery skin and her Memphis-style dry rub ribs are just that – a little dry. Once again, her dessert ends up saving her as the banana pudding is a hit.

Lu’s chicken pillows has one of her great sauces, a honey barbecue. Then comes the Christopher show: his pulled pork has no major dings, his brisket is smoked well but doesn’t quite have the bark, and his ribs aren’t as life-changing as he assumed they would be. Eddie focused on the sides and his collards and barbecue beans seem standard.

In the end, the 2+1 contestant Team Eddie gets the W and Team Michael is also safe. As may have been foreshadowed by all the earlier infighting, Team Bobby is on the chopping block. All the proteins had their issues, but Terry goes home for his greasy pork. Could have probably seen this coming, as he is the lone remaining non-competition contestant.

Bells for Terry, the trash talker-in-chief.

Christopher Prieto Watch: Christopher handles the bulk of the meats for the team with seemingly mixed results during judging, but helps get them to safety with the overall win. He continues to rub some folks the wrong way, and this week that includes his captain Eddie. In the end, he is a big part of his teams W despite the misstep on his bbq beans that Eddie had to step in and fix. He moves on to next week, though I do wonder if Lu will soon tire of his (over) confidence.

What was your favorite part of episode 5 of BBQ Brawl season 2? Leave your response in the comments and be sure to check back next week for a recap of episode 6.

Recap: BBQ Brawl S2E4 – “Game Day BBQ”

Monk: In a bit of a change of pace, I’m going to try my hand at TV recapping for the second season of BBQ Brawl, which airs for *checks notes* 10 episodes *gulp* on Monday nights at 9pm ET on Food Network. 10 episodes? Well let’s see how this goes…

For the second week in a row as the previous week’s losing team, Eddie gets to choose the advantage challenge and goes with chicken wings, giving the contestants 30 minutes to produce their best versions. A lot of contestants go with some variation on the standard buffalo wing but a few stand out.

David on Team Michael actually owns a chicken wing business, and his fennel wings seem to intrigue the captains and judges. Ara uses his fine dining experience and decides to confit the wings in duck fat on the grill, which will keep the ducks juicy and prevent them from overcooking. Terry’s honey barbecue wings are also promising, and Lu actually goes with a cranberry sauce wing using the full wing. Lu actually owns her own sauce company that has her sauces in “over 700 stores nationwide” but in the end it’s her teammate Christopher and his “triple threat” wings that are smoked, fried, and then finished on the grill with an jalapeno apricot sauce is declared the winner which gives their team the advantage of Eddie being able to call timeouts on each of the other teams for 10 minutes.

For the team brawl challenge, the theme continues in the form of a Tailgate Feast where the teams have 3 hours to produce a gameday-themed meal. And of course, there is the looming advantage for Team Eddie hanging over the other two teams. Depending on how much of a stinker he wants to be, he could really screw one or both of those teams up with his timing.

Which of course, he does to Team Michael roughly an hour and a half in when he catches Terry with his racks of ribs on direct heat. This spells the end of those particular racks, but Terry does have one leftover that he can try to salvage in his remaining time. During the timeout, the bickering between Terry and Taylor that started at the beginning of the cook continues. Taylor asks Terry why his ribs were on direct heat to begin with (a perfectly valid question) before trying to brainstorm what to potentially do with ribs once they are out of timeout. Terry shuts down and doesn’t want any feedback from Taylor or the rest of his teammates, only worrying about his ribs.

Team Michael smartly learns from Terry’s mistake and wraps their meats in foil and gets them to a good place before their time out is called. David is a little peeved and worries about the bark on his ribs but in the end he and his teammates avoid disaster.

For Team Eddie’s “Rub You the Right Way Tailgate”, they smartly provide each judge a beer. Lu makes a smoked queso dip and chicken lollipops while Christopher makes bbq rice and ribs. Lu’s smoked queso dip is a little broken while her chicken lollipops look great but the skin that is wrapped down over the leg is a little chewy, getting into the way of the dark meat. Christopher has more success starting with the ribs glazed with a sauce from Lu, which Carson calls “life changing.” His bbq rice gets less praise but overall, the judges like their tailgate feast and calls the ribs some of the best food they’ve had thus far.

Team Bobby’s feast is dubbed “Don’t Call it a Comeback Tailgate.” Taylor makes mac and cheese balls but Brook finds that the goat cheese overpowers the rest of the cheese and Rodney prefers the crispy outside to the inside. Terry, whose ribs were the victims of the timeout, scrambles and collaborates with Bobby to get gochujang pork loins and the one remaining rack of ribs done in less than 1.5 hours. The pork loin turns out excellent but the ribs were cooked a little too quickly. Erica’s tostadas with ribeye suffer from a chewy tostada and too little steak while Brendan’s Texas Twinkie-stuffed quail, with a bacon-wrapped jalapeno stuffed inside a quail. The bacon loses its crispiness inside the quail, which itself was overcooked.

Team Michael’s “All Hands on Deck Tailgate” is all made to all be eaten with hands and is served with mojitos. David makes a roasted corn salsa and a St. Louis-style rib with harissa and ancho chiles, which the judges like the flavor of but find to be a bit overdone. Brittani’s baby back ribs have nutmeg in the rub and the judges generally like. The final rib is a beef rib from Ara that could use a little more flavor.

Team Eddie wins the challenge on the back of Christopher’s ribs glazed with Lu’s sauce while Team Michael is also safe. The means Bobby’s team is finally heading to the chopping block, and their team of 4 will be reduced to 3. In the end it seems that Erica’s ribeye tostadas and Brendan’s quail are the least successful dishes, and one of the will be eliminated. That ends up being Brendan, and he is ok with that decision because he is embarrassed at his dry quail. Erica and Terry are both visibly shaken at their first time on the bottom.

Bells for Brendan, the west Texas barbecue man who feels he is a better man because of the experience.

This episode marks the halfway point through the season, and it looks like next week looks to be more of a “low and slow” challenge that shifts (at least for one episode) from live fire cooking/grilling to more traditional barbecue. Hopefully that will continue past episode 6.

Christopher Prieto Watch: Christopher is called the MVP of the day between his winning wings and his fantastic ribs. While his cockiness gets called out by David and he gets into a little tit-a-tat with Bobby about “showing Bobby Flay a thing or two about chicken wings” and gets this reaction from him:

On this day at least Christopher backs it up. But it seems like his cockiness is rubbing some contestants the wrong way, so it’ll be worth tracking. Next week, Christopher seemingly gets some props from Rodney during next week’s “low and slow” challenge so his head may continue to balloon with confidence.

What was your favorite part of episode 4 of BBQ Brawl season 2? Leave your response in the comments and be sure to check back next week for a recap of episode 5.

Recap: BBQ Brawl S2E3 – “BBQ Hacks”

Monk: In a bit of a change of pace, I’m going to try my hand at TV recapping for the second season of BBQ Brawl, which airs for *checks notes* 10 episodes *gulp* on Monday nights at 9pm ET on Food Network. 10 episodes? Well let’s see how this goes…

As it goes this season, the loser of last week’s challenge gets to pick the first challenge, and Eddie goes with “Good for You ‘Cue” for a healthier kind of barbecue with the twist of just the captains cooking this week to gain their team a potential advantage in the Team Brawl. And it seems that Eddie is still a bit salty with his favorite chef Max going home last week. I wonder how Christopher feels about that or if he is even aware. I also have to say, it seems a bit early for the contestants to get to take a challenge off.

Bobby wins the challenge with his charred eggplant and grilled shrimp over Eddie’s steak salad and Michael’s grilled halibut. That earns him the advantage of Rodney Scott starting his team’s campfire in the “Campfire Feast” before the timer starts, essentially giving his team a solid 10-15 minute head start. With a fire master like Rodney taking care of that piece (even utilizing bacon fat to get it started), the team can focus on meal planning while the other teams have to play catch up.

Terry gives his team a scare with his fire-tending skills but ultimately gets his sliced brisket seared so he can grind for for his barbecue beans in addition to barbecue chicken. Brendan is making a classic hot guts sausage while Erica decides to do a Mexican corn salad, and pastry chef Taylor takes on dessert in the form of a corn layer cake with blueberry compote. Ultimately, the barbecue beans are scrapped when the texture gets too mushy and Bobby nixes it in favor of some last minute rosemary potatoes which he referred to as “recovery potatoes” during judging, much too Bobby’s dismay.

For Team Eddie, Christopher takes campfire chili made with short rib even though Lu was hoping to be able to make chili and is apparently “very, very good at it.” Instead, she takes jalapeno poppers and Mexican street corn while Megan takes a Dutch baby dessert which is cross between a crepe and a pancake.

The disaster for Christopher that was previewed last week comes when his pot falls into the fire when the rocks apparently shifted but lucky for him his campfire chili avoids falling completely into the fire. Still, not ideal and could play a part in the judging.

Team Michael has Brittani making lump crab and corn fritters while Ara and David tackle a chuck roast and bone-in pork chops and Ara makes a smoked blueberry panna cotta for dessert. Brittani comments to the camera about having to step back to men in this industry, but gets her revenge during judging where she gets “bite of the day” for her crab and corn fritters, and ultimately lifts Team Michael to be the first safe team of the day.

Between the other teams, Team Bobby narrowly edges out Team Eddie in what the judges say was the toughest decision yet. Bobby once again avoids the bottom.

Team Eddie joins the judges in their “Barbecutie Clubhouse” yet again this week. The Mexican street corn and the jalapeno poppers from Lu are called out as favorites, so it comes down to Christopher’s burnt-ish tasting chili and Megan’s Dutch baby that wasn’t quite the right texture. In the end, Megan goes home which she half expects after her her team lands in the bottom.

Bells for Megan, yet another cooking show contestant who “takes one for the team” and ends up going home for a dessert she didn’t want to make.

Christopher Prieto Watch: Christopher narrowly avoids going home for his short rib chili which had a slight burnt taste. He continues to be confident but after a big first impression in the premiere, Christopher has been humbled a little bit the past two episodes. Team Eddie is down to just two contestants, so he and Lu will surely be busy for next week’s tailgate challenge.

What was your favorite part of episode 3 of BBQ Brawl season 2? Leave your response in the comments and be sure to check back next week for a recap of episode 4.

Recap: BBQ Brawl S2E2 – “Hometown Favorites”

Monk: In a bit of a change of pace, I’m going to try my hand at TV recapping for the second season of BBQ Brawl, which airs for *checks notes* 10 episodes *gulp* on Monday nights at 9pm ET on Food Network. 10 episodes? Well let’s see how this goes…

This week, since Symon’s team was on the bottom in the super-sized premiere episode, he gets to choose the first challenge this week, so he chooses to go with “Pork and Cabbage.” Each contestant gets to choose what that means to her or him as long as there is a personal connection.

Christopher Prieto, the lone NC contestant, goes with a kielbasa sausage with a German slaw that the judges find just alright but slightly underwhelming while the other contestants go with various pork proteins in the form of sausages, pork steaks, pork belly, ground pork, and pork tenderloins. I would think pork steak would have been a great call in such a short amount of time but the judges didn’t call out that dish from David.

In the end, Taylor’s meatloaf from Team Bobby, Brittani’s kielbasa from Team Michael, and Max’s jerk pork from Team Eddie are the three winners from the respective teams, with Max taking home the top prize and getting Team Eddie a second win and an advantage in the Team Brawl, a “BBQ dessert bar.” That advantage ends up being baking equipment that only they can use in the challenge while other teams have to use manual labor.

Team Eddie not only has the equipment but also collectively seem to tie their dessert dishes together the best in the conception stage through the use of booze in each dessert while Team Michael goes with “sauces” and Team Bobby going with “nostalgia.” Despite not winning the first challenge, Team Bobby actually turns out to have an advantage of their own, since Taylor is a classically-trained pastry chef and is also able to help her fellow teammates as they encounter various challenges.

Speaking of challenges, as the 90 minutes chugs along Team Michael hasn’t actually been able to make any of their sauces due to their various issues with Brittani’s sweet potato fritters not forming together initially, Michael’s pudding not setting, and David’s gooey butter cake not cooking all the way through. Only Ara seems to have it together with his blueberry tart, but the sauce theme is scrapped.

For Team Eddie’s “Booze Cruise” theme, each contestant has some issues with his or her dish according to the judges: Meagan’s tart shells are raw, Christopher’s smoked peach cobbler doesn’t have a ton of smoke, Max’s smoked and flambeed plantains (over of three dishes he makes) are not quite cooked all the way through, and Lu’s smoked Kahlua chocolate drinking dessert could have been colder.

Team Bobby’s “Nostalgic American Desserts” does predictably better in terms of nitpicks, with no major dings for Bobby’s blackberry shortcake, Brendan’s monkey bread, Erica’s bananas foster, Terry’s smoked peach and blueberry cobbler, and Taylor’s chocolate torte.

Finally, turns out the disastrous cook for Team Michael’s “Hometown Flavors” doesn’t spell immediate doom for the end result. Michael’s chocolate and banana parfait comes together at the end, David is able to salvage the mostly cooked-through corners of his gooey butter cake, Ara’s smoked blueberry tart has a crispy graham cracker crust, and Brittani’s marshmallow stuffed sweet potato fritter is fun even if the marshmallow in the dish name dissolved in the fritter.

For the results of the Team Brawl, Team Michael actually gets named the first safe team much to their relief after finishing on the bottom last week. Team Bobby again is safe, so that leads to Team Eddie on the bottom after winning last week and acting a little cocky. Max’s lack of focus in making three desserts is his downfall, and he heads home after Eddie declaring him a frontrunner earlier in the episode. Classic cooking competition mistake: focus on one good dish instead of making multiple mediocre ones.

Bells for Max, the king of carribean flavors.

Christopher Prieto Watch: Christopher floats in the middle of the pack this week and while his team is on the bottom he doesn’t make any critical mistakes that lead to his exit. Next week looks like he may have some issues with cooking over a campfire so I look forward to seeing if and how he gets through it.

What was your favorite part of episode 2 of BBQ Brawl season 2? Leave your response in the comments and be sure to check back next week for a recap of episode 3.